Fraser Institute

[Search]
[Media Releases]
[Events]
[Online Publications]
[Order Publications]
[Student]
[Radio]
[National Media Archive]
[Membership]
[Other Resources]
[About Us]


The
Economic Freedom
Network

 

Poor Seniors?

Chris Sarlo

The financial status of Canada's seniors is the subject of many academic and journalistic studies. As our population ages, we can expect the elderly and their standard of living to come under even more scrutiny than in the past. While it is widely acknowledged that the lot of seniors has improved markedly over the past 25 years, there is still a prevailing view that today's elderly (and single elderly women, in particular) are among the worst off in society. The evidence, at least that using income as an indicator of the material standard of living, does not support that view.

In 1995, the latest year for which detailed information is available, Statistics Canada's Survey of Consumer Finances reports that about 12 percent of Canada's people were 65 years of age or older. These seniors lived in households with an after tax income of just over $30,000. This is fully $8,000 lower than the average after tax income of households with no seniors. However, the average size of households with seniors was only 1.84 persons compared to 2.56 for households without seniors. The per capita incomes of senior households was, in fact, ten percent higher than that in non senior households.

However, per capita income comparisons are very deceiving because they ignore any consideration of economies of scale in living. Economists have long recognized that the costs of living, especially shelter costs, do not increase in proportion to the number of people in the household. Sharing housing, certain consumer durables such as televisions, furniture, automobiles, and dishwashers, etc., results in more efficient use of those items. Hence, five people living on an income of $40,000 would each very likely have a higher standard of living than one person living on $15,000. The larger the household, the less expensive it is for each person in the household to maintain a given standard of living. So, the higher per capita income in households with seniors would be offset, more or less, by the scale economies consideration.

Working in the other direction, however, is mortgage-free home ownership. About 60 percent of senior-headed households own their homes mortgage-free, compared with only 22 percent for households headed by a non-senior. This means that, in general, seniors are likely to have lower shelter costs. Indeed, the latest Family Expenditure Survey (1992) by Statistics Canada clearly shows that senior households have substantially lower shelter costs than non-senior households, even when family size is accounted for.

In 1995 . . . the per capita incomes of senior households was . . . ten percent higher than that in non senior households.

The situation of some single elderly people is frequently the subject of heart-wrenching media stories. Clearly, there are many single seniors who are lonely and have health problems. In addition, anyone living alone has higher per capita costs due to the failure to take advantage of scale economies. However, the typical senior has sufficient after tax income to live comfortably. In 1995, there were 262,855 single elderly men and 781,636 single elderly women living on their own. There was considerable "bunching" of their incomes, with 56 percent of the men and 60 percent of the women reporting incomes between $12,000 and $20,000. Most importantly, only 2.9 percent of the single men and 2.7 percent of the single women had after tax incomes below $10,000.

Click Here to View Table 1

Click Here to View Figure 1

Of more importance is the poverty status of our elderly. Using the basic needs approach to defining poverty, the poverty rate of senior citizens has fallen dramatically over the past two decades. The poverty rate of Canada's seniors is now below 1 percent, compared with about 5 percent for the non-senior population. The accompanying graph shows the poverty rate comparison between senior and non-senior groups since 1973.

Therefore, it is not at all clear that Canadian seniors are "worse off" in any material sense than non-seniors. Their standard of living, once household income, household size, scale economies in living and average shelter cost are accounted for, is comparable to that of non-seniors. And there are many fewer seniors than non-seniors living below the poverty line. The image of seniors often promulgated by the social welfare establishment—hungry, ill housed and destitute—is simply not consistent with the facts.





 info@fraserinstitute.ca

You can contact us at the above email address for any comments or information requests. Please report any dead links or technical problems.

 
If you know someone who would be interested in this web page, please enter their email address below, and we will forward this URL to them:
Email Address:
Last Modified: Wednesday, October 20, 1999.